It was Pep Guardiola’s Barcelona that made millions fall in love with the beautiful game. It felt like what we watched transcended the game. A well-oiled system with each element meticulously designed to do its part. It felt like magic. Carlo Ancelotti is the only manager to win 4 European Cups and a league title in each of the 5 big leagues. Yet, he doesn’t have a distinct style of play or system. Welcome to the opposites who both attract millions of football fans worldwide. By Atharv Behind the supernatural talent pool in Barcelona, was one of the most logical, meticulously designed systems of football the world has ever seen. Each player needed to slot themselves in like a lego piece. They would simply have to fit in or not play. On the other hand, Ancelotti picks the best players he has and puts them in their favoured positions to make the whole team function. One seeks to bring order and eliminate any sort of unpredictability, while the other capitalizes on chaos. How is it possible to have such wildly contrasting football philosophies, yet both be so highly successful in the modern game? Guardiola is a visionary theorist who fundamentally changed the way the game is played, developing and refining his concept of “Juego de posición”. Known for his possession-based brand of football, Guardiola’s teams excel in commanding games through intricate passing movements. He meticulously drills down into the smallest of details and makes them matter. He decides the system to be played in each and every game and reduces the responsibility placed upon the players, essentially making their decisions for them. He plans in such a way that he can control the game as much as possible. For instance, at Barcelona, Guardiola started Thierry Henry at right wing. However, Henry, being Henry, shifted to the left side and started combining with Messi. Eventually, Henry scored. 1-0 to Barcelona vs Sporting Lisbon and everything seemed perfectly normal. They went in for the halftime break, all happy, and Pep took Henry off, essentially saying “when I have a plan, you respect my plan.” After Pep won all there was to win at Barcelona, he only went and did it again at City, taking the Barcelona blueprint and recreating it in the Premier League, highlighting to a great extent how his system can be employed in different contexts. As he describes his philosophy: “I don't like it when a player says, 'I like freedom; I want to play for myself.' Because the player has to understand he is part of a team with 10 other players. If everyone wants to be a jazz musician, it will be chaos. They will not be a team, and nothing will be possible.” On the other hand, what specifically makes Carlo Ancelotti unique is his desire to make life uncomfortable for the opponent through different modes of attack. His teams are perfectly capable of a controlled build up through the thirds. However, they are far from dogmatic in their playing approach and much more than other top teams, they are happy to find less controlled routes to goal. What makes his teams so special is their ability to adapt to the opposition and situation, meaning they are perfectly tailored to tackle that specific situation. As Ancelotti captures it “here is something I firmly believe in, and that is if you think and act as part of a team, individual recognitions will come on their own. Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence win championships." He believes in a brand of football that benefits his players the most, and he, himself, has no primary guiding principle. He is acknowledged as one of the best man-managers in the game and has a special ability to connect with the players. He simply looks at his players and finds a structure that allows everyone to be in their best positions, placing the utmost responsibility upon the players and trusting them to deliver day in and day out. "I think that trust is a fundamental aspect of any relationship, and it's no different with players", he says. "If you trust your players, they will trust you back, and that's crucial for the success of the team." Despite both succeeding all across Europe, they have their faults and are often criticized for their approaches. Guardiola has been often criticized for overthinking tactics before crucial games, which has led to some disappointing results. Moreover, he has faced challenges in managing certain players’ egos, leading to significant conflicts throughout his managerial career. For instance, during his time at Barcelona, Zlatan Ibrahimovic grew frustrated with Pep Guardiola’s management style and tactics. Playing in the shadow of Lionel Messi, Ibrahimovic exposed his discontent and clashed with Guardiola, leading to a strained relationship between the two, eventually leading to Ibrahimovic leaving after only 2 seasons at the club. On the flip side of things, Ancelotti’s tactical flexibility has also been a weakness in his coaching career. While he is known for adapting his style based on the players at his disposal, there have been instances where his tactical decisions have been criticized. For example, in a match where Real Madrid faced Atletico Madrid, Ancelotti’s choice of a 4-3-2-1 formating, resembling a Christmas tree setup, was heavily scrutinized. The narrowness of the formation left Real Madrid highly exposed to Atletico’s wide threat, as they struggled to contain the opposing wing back’s and provide adequate defensive cover on the flanks. This incident effectively depicts how Ancelotti's system can come crashing down if not thought out properly. Photo by Connor Coyne on Unsplash The journeys of Guardiola and Ancelotti exemplify the beauty of football, showcasing how two completely contrasting approaches can lead to success in their own right. Their stories remind us that football is not just a game but a platform for creativity, innovation and teamwork. It is a celebration of individual and collective brilliance, where talent, skill, strategy and adaptability intertwine to create moments of magic.
As we reflect on the legacies of Pep Guardiola and Carlo Ancelotti, we have to remind ourselves that football is much more than a sport; it is a canvas for endless possibilities. Their contrasting paths perfectly exemplify the boundless possibilities within the game and will continue to do so for years to come.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Categories
All
Archives
May 2024
|